About
Instagram
YouTube
Disclaimer
Dr Esselstyn: Nuts, Seeds & Avocados
10 Dec 2022
Disclaimer
Dr Esselstyn recommends 10% total fats. In order to sustain such a low fat percentage on long term basis, he recommends zero nuts because nuts are addictive. He says that we may derive EFAs (Essential Fatty Acids) from 1-2 tbsp ground flaxeed or chia seeds. Let's understand these points step by step.
Total Fat Percentage

In the article In Cholesterol Lowering, Moderation Kills (Cleve Clin J Med 2000 Aug;67(8):560-4, also available at Dr Esselstyn's website), Dr Esselstyn says:

"The high fat American diet is responsible for an epidemic of coronary artery disease. A plant-based diet with less than 10% fat will prevent coronary disease from developing, halt the progress of existing disease, and even reverse the disease in many patients. Given proper support and education, motivated patients with a history of coronary disease can follow this diet and prevent future cardiac events."

Table W3 of A way to reverse CAD? by Esselstyn et al, J Family Practice, Vol 63, No 7, 2014 (available at Dr Esselstyn's website) on pages 364a-364b summarizes trials by both Dr Ornish and Dr Esselstyn; the target fat percentage in all of these landmark studies was 10%.

More info: Dr Esselstyn: Can We Become Heart Disease Proof? summarizes Dr Esselstyn's studies. The Emphasis on Low Fat showcases the recommendations of multiple Whole Food Plant-Based doctors and researchers — many of them recommend 10% to 15% total fat intake. EFAs (Essential Fatty Acids) are a complex topic; see articles in this section: Essential Fatty Acids.

Are Nuts Healthy?

Studies on nuts show that nuts are awesome! Nuts help us lose weight, lower cholesterol levels and promote health in many other ways! Still, the question remains: how many nuts and seeds should we eat? Only a few tablespoons, or several handfuls daily?

Whole Food Plant-Based luminaries suggest that total fat intake be in the ballpark of 10% to 15% of total calories. See The Emphasis on Low Fat.

What does Dr Esselstyn recommend?

No Nuts!

Dr Esselstyn FAQ says:

"As nuts are a rich source of saturated fats, my preference is no nuts for heart disease patients. That also eliminates peanuts and peanut butter even though peanuts are officially a legume. For those with established heart disease to add more saturated fat that is in nuts is inappropriate. For people with no heart disease who want to eat nuts and avocado and are able to achieve a cholesterol of 150 and LDL of 80 or under without cholesterol lowering drugs, some nuts and avocado are acceptable. Chestnuts are the one nut, very low in fat, it is ok to eat." — Dr Esselstyn

Dr Esselstyn makes three main points:

(1) Nuts are addictive: At offset 0:50 of this video, Dr Esselstyn says,

"How many times have I seen a patient who would eat 1 nut? Nuts are highly addictive! And if I ever go on record saying, "Nuts are OK", they're going to be in the glove compartment, they will be in the bathroom, in the kitchen, the dining room, the hallway, the work bench. That's just not what I want for my patients."

(2) Lack of studies on heart disease reversal with nuts:

"On Page 69 of my book, I have a passage where I say that I do not object to patients who do not have documented cardiovascular disease having nuts. However, once a diagnosis of cardiovascular disease is established, I do not like my patients to have nuts and avocados and additional fat because I have yet to see a single study in the medical literature where someone has patients who were seriously ill with cardiovascular disease and let them have peanut butter, nuts and cashew sauce, and have their disease reversed. I haven't seen that study."

We don't have studies showing that WFPB + nuts reverses heart disease. In future, such a study may emerge and it may turn out that eating extra nuts & avocados is just fine for heart disease reversal. However, so far, we don't have such a study — this is a gap in scientific knowledge as of 2021.

(3) EFAs from flax & chia: Dr Esselstyn says that we can get sufficient amounts of Essential Fatty Acids (EFAs) from 1-2 tbsp ground flax and chia. This is explored in a section below.

Essential Fatty Acids From Flax & Chia

Essential Fatty Acids (EFAs) are those which our body cannot produce, so we need to consume them via diet. Dr Esselstyn encourages a low fat system in which we avoid all high fat foods like nuts, nut butters, coconut, avocado, coconut and even seeds (with the exception of flax, chia, hempseed). Details in Dr Esselstyn's FAQ.

Omega 3's — How May I Get My Omega 3's? This article explains:

"Omega 3's are essential fatty acids supplied in adequate amounts in people consuming plant based nutrition with plenty of green leafy vegetables. However 1-2 tablespoons of flax seed meal or chia seeds daily is perfectly acceptable. Avoid flax seed oil."

Seeds (sunflower, pumpkin, sesame, etc.) Are seeds ok to eat? This article explains:

"1 -2 tablespoons of ground flax seeds or chia seeds daily for omega 3 are appropriate for everyone to eat including heart patients, if they wish. Some seeds baked in bread or crackers is acceptable. Just don't eat handfuls."

Fish Oil — Should I take fish oil? This article explains:

"Fish oil is not essential. Fish get their omega 3 from plants. Patients on fish oil are also at increased risk for bleeding, and studies now indicate they are of no benefit for heart disease patients."

"It is difficult to be deficient in Omega 3 if eating 1-2 tablespoons of flax seed meal or chia seeds and green leafy vegetables at several meals. There is also research that suggests that those on plant based nutrition become highly efficient in their own manufacture of omega 3."

Flax Seed Oil/ Flax Seed Meal/ Chia Seeds — What about flax seed oil? This article explains:

"Flax seed meal (flax needs to be ground) or Chia seeds are well tolerated and supply a bonus of omega 3 using 1 or 2 tablespoons on cereal daily. Avoid flax seed oil."

These points are echoed in support groups for Dr Esselstyn's guidelines, and in videos by Ann and Jane Esselstyn:

"A few seeds are fine. 1 tbsp chia or flaxseed. Flaxseed need to be ground. Even some sesame seeds or pumpkin seeds are fine. Don't eat handfuls / cupfuls." —offset 15:27 of Jane & Ann's video.

"1-2 Tablespoons ground flaxseed and/or chia seeds daily, maximum of 2 tablespoons " — FaceBook Support Group (2020).

Coconuts, Coconut Milk, Coconut Cream, Coconut Yogurt

"Avoid all high fat foods like nuts, nut butters, coconut, avocado, coconut, seeds (see flaxseed/chia reference below) An olive or two as a condiment is fine. Tofu can be eaten occasional, although occasionally has not been defined." (from this FaceBook Group).

"For heart disease patients, steer clear of nuts, avocado and coconut." If you don't have heart disease, a handful (1/4 cup) of nuts is fine, especially walnuts. See offset 13:11 of Jane & Ann's video.

Coconut Milk: At offset 13:44 of Jane & Ann's video, Ann focuses her attention on coconut milk! She opens a can of coconut milk and explains that it's loaded with saturated fats! Ann also mentions that vegan ice creams and vegan yogurts often have coconut milk or coconut cream! See Point 9 in Ann Esselstyn's article from 2013.

Coconut Milk, Coconut Cream & Indian Cuisine: I have noticed that a lot of my Indian friends gravitate towards recipes with coconut milk! Please browse through Saturated Fats in Coconuts to understand why coconut milk is highly discouraged for heart health.

Coconut Extract: Those who love coconut in their meals may buy coconut extract; it imparts coconut flavor.

Further Reading

What do other Whole Food Plant-Based luminaries say about oil, fats, nuts, seeds and avocados?

© Copyright 2008—2024, Gurmeet Manku.