About
Instagram
YouTube
Disclaimer
CRAP Foods: Calorie Rich And Processed
28 Dec 2020
Disclaimer

Source: Cut the Calorie Rich And Processed (CRAP) Foods (6 mins, 2020) by Dr Greger.

What are CRAP foods? CRAP is an acronym for Calorie Rich And Processed foods.

Dr Greger's video on CRAP foods: Cut the Calorie Rich And Processed (CRAP) Foods (6 mins, 2020) is insightful! It touches upon the relationship between calorie density (a concept popularized by Jeff Novick through his infographics and talks), our innate preferences for high calorie density foods, how food industry creates unnatural foods with high calorie density (by stripping away parts of natural foods which make them have low calorie density) and how humans are addicted to foods with high calorie density.

What is Calorie Density? See Calorie Density — check out this article; a mere glance on an infographic by ForksOverKnives will explain what 'calorie density' means and why it's important.

First, Dr Greger explains that for foods with low calorie density (fruits and veggies found in nature), the natural preferences of 4-year old children correlate with calorie density, shown by the pic above.

"They prefer bananas over berries; carrots over cucumbers. Well duh, isn't that just a preference for sweetness? No, they also prefer potatoes over peaches, and green beans over melon, just like monkeys prefer avocados over bananas. We appear to have an inborn drive to maximize calories per mouthful."

… but what happens to our instincts when we encounter high calorie density foods, going beyond fruits and vegetables?

"All the foods the researchers tested naturally had less than 500 calories per pound (bananas topped the chart at about 400). Something funny happens when you start going over that. We lose our ability to differentiate. Over the natural range of calorie densities, we have an uncanny aptitude to pick out the subtle distinctions. However, once you start heading towards bacon, cheese, and chocolate territory, which can reach thousands of calories per pound, our perceptions become relatively numb to the differences."

… how are "high calorie density" foods prepared by industry?

The food industry exploits our innate biological vulnerabilities by stripping crops down into almost pure calories — straight sugar, oil (which is pretty much pure fat), and white flour (which is mostly refined starch). First, they have to remove the fiber, because it effectively has zero calories. Run brown rice through a mill to make white, and you lose about two-thirds of the fiber. Turn whole wheat flour into white, and lose 75 percent. Or, you can run crops through animals (to make meat, dairy, and eggs), and remove 100 percent of the fiber. What you're left with is CRAP (an acronym used by one of my favorite dieticians, Jeff Novick): Calorie-Rich And Processed (CRAP) foods."

… are "high calorie density" foods addictive?

"Calories are condensed in the same way plants are turned into addictive drugs like opiates and cocaine: concentration, crystallization, distillation, and extraction. They even appear to activate the same reward pathways in the brain. Put people with "food addiction" in an MRI scanner and show them a picture of a chocolate milkshake, and the areas that light up in their brains are the same as when cocaine addicts are shown a video of crack smoking."

… are humans addicted to "food" or only "foods with high calorie density"?

"'Food' addiction is a misnomer. People don't suffer out-of-control eating behaviors to food in general. We don't tend to compulsively crave carrots. Milkshakes are packed with sugar and fat: two of the signals to our brain of calorie density. When people are asked to rate different foods in terms of cravings and loss of control, most incriminated was a load of CRAP — highly processed foods, like doughnuts, along with cheese and meat. Those least related to problematic eating behaviors? Fruits and vegetables. Calorie density may be the reason people don't get up in the middle of the night and binge on broccoli."

CRAP Food Videos

The two videos below are really awesome! Dr Goldhammer's video is both hilarious and insightful! Worth watching. Dr Greger's video is technical and was summarized above.

Calories Per Pound by Dr Goldhamer

(8 mins) A short, hilarious exposition by Dr Goldhamer. Worth watching to understand why we should diligently avoid eating processed foods, sugars & oils for weight loss. Once the key ideas in this video are grasped, we can start understanding why dehydration of whole juicy food sources in an oven is also a bad idea — we should do that sparingly.

(2020) Cut the Calorie-Rich-And-Processed (CRAP) Foods

(6 mins) Transcript. Dr Greger's summary: "We have an uncanny ability to pick out the subtle distinctions in calorie density of foods, but only within the natural range."

An insightful video by Dr Greger that was summarized in this article earlier.

Are Processed Foods Addictive?
(2022) Do Healthy Fast-Food Options Lead to Healthier Choices?

(9 mins) Transcript. Dr Greger's summary: "Adding a healthy option can actually drive people to make even worse choices, thanks to a mind-blowing glitch of human psychology."

(2022) Ultra-Processed Junk Food Put to the Test

(8 mins) Transcript. Dr Greger's summary: "What happened when ultra-processed foods were matched for calories, sugar, fat, and fiber content in the first randomized controlled trial?"

© Copyright 2008—2024, Gurmeet Manku.