About
Instagram
YouTube
Disclaimer
Seaweed & Cancer
2 Dec 2020
Disclaimer
Soy foods, mushrooms, green tea and seaweed are four commonly found ingredients in Asian cuisines (China, Japan, …) that are believed to protect us against cancer. I grew up in India. None of these four ingredients is commonly used in Indian cuisine. So whenever I meet friends from Indian sub-continent, I tell them about all four.

Seaweed has other health benefits too! The videos below focus on seaweed and cancer only.

Cancer Protection from Seaweed

Which Seaweed to Help Prevent Breast Cancer? (2014) by Dr Greger suggests that seaweed may reduce breast cancer risk. By how much? And what's the mechanism?

How much?

"Well, a population study comparing women with breast cancer to women without found that consuming a single sheet of nori a day may cut a woman's odds of breast cancer in half." — Dr Greger

What's the mechanism?

"We think it's because seaweed favorably alters estrogen metabolism, likely due to modulating women's gut bacteria. The more seaweed we eat, the less estrogen we have in our system, which may lower breast cancer risk." — Dr Greger

"The breast cancer protection may be because of all the fiber in sea vegetables, or because seaweed may block the enzyme that undermines our body's attempt to flush out excess hormones. Or seaweed may somehow interfere with estrogen binding to estrogen receptors. Whatever the cause, to effectively lower their estrogen levels, Asian women may be able to get away with about one sheet of nori a day, but American women are physically so much larger that it may take closer to two."

Questions in my mind: If we already follow WFPB guidelines diligently, would it help to consume seaweed to protect ourselves from breast cancer even more? What are the marginal or incremental benefits of seaweed over and above WFPB, as practiced by somebody of Indian sub-continent origin?

(2013) Which Seaweed Is Most Protective Against Breast Cancer?

(5 mins) Transcript. Dr Greger's summary: "Nori seaweed snacks may favorably alter estrogen metabolism by modulating women's gut flora, resulting in decreased breast cancer risk."

Associated blog post: Which Seaweed to Help Prevent Breast Cancer? (2014).

Cancer Risk with Seaweed?

Hijiki is a seaweed that may be contaminated with arsenic. A excerpt from the video below:

As you can see, rice contains more of the toxic inorganic arsenic than seafood, with one exception. Hijiki, an edible seaweed—a hundred times more contaminated than rice, leading some researchers to refer to it as the “so-called edible…seaweed.” Governments have started to agree. “In 2001, the Canadian [government] advised the public not to eat hijiki.” Then, the UK, the rest of Europe, Australia, New Zealand, then China “advised the public not to eat hijiki, and banned imports and sales” of the stuff. Japan, where they actually have a hijiki industry, just advised moderation.

So, I’d recommend to avoid hijiki due to its excess arsenic content, and avoid kelp due to its excess iodine. But all other seaweeds should be fine, as long as you don’t eat them with too much rice.

(2017) Cancer Risk from Arsenic in Rice & Seaweed

(8 mins) Transcript.

© Copyright 2008—2025, Gurmeet Manku.