About
Instagram
YouTube
Disclaimer
Portion Control and Calorie Counting
25 Mar 2019
Disclaimer
Calorie Counting and Portion Control are two common techniques in popular diets. When following Whole Food Plant-Based (WFPB) guidelines, we practice neither (except for nuts n seeds)! Ain't that lovely? Let's look at the guidelines in more detail.
Calorie Counting & Portion Control

Do we have to count calories?

Dr Fuhrman: "Not at all!" explains Joel Fuhrman in this article: Q&A about the Nutritarian Diet. Excerpts from the article:

Question: Do I have to count calories?

Answer by Fuhrman: "Not at all! You only have to count calories when you eat high-calorie, low-nutrient processed foods or commercial animal products that are not natural. Even though the books may benchmark average consumption for men and women, you never have to count calories again. Of course, we all need differing amounts of calories, based on our size, activity level and genetics. This plan allows you to get back in touch with your body's instinctual sensations that tell you when you need to eat.

Natural plant foods are relatively low in calories, rich in fiber, high in water content and full of fiber, so they fill you up easily, without getting excess calories. Then, with time, your body will give you accurate signals to tell you how much it needs. You'll eat until you're satisfied, all the time!"

Q: Do I need to control portion size?

Answer by Fuhrman: "Just eat until you've had enough. You should not eat until you are uncomfortable."

Dr McDougall: Effects of 7 days on an ad libitum low-fat vegan diet: the McDougall Program cohort by John McDougall et al, Nutrition Journal, 2014, 13:99. PDF Copy. Another copy: here. Excerpt:

[Patients received] dietary counseling and were fed a low-fat (≤ 10% of calories) diet based on minimally refined plant foods ad libitum to satiety.

Meals were served buffet-style, and participants were encouraged to eat to the full satisfaction of their appetite.

(5 mins, 2022) Lose Weight and Get Healthy without Portion Control
… But Do Not Binge on Nuts and Seeds !!

We have to exercise Portion Control for only one component of our food plate: nuts and seeds. How many nuts n seeds should we eat every day? I follow the guidelines at Esselstyn FAQ (search for "nuts", then "seeds").

(Copied from Esselstyn FAQ in March 2019)

Nuts — What about nuts? I hear so many different opinions?

Answer by Esselstyn: "As nuts are a rich source of saturated fats, my preference is no nuts for heart disease patients. That also eliminates peanuts and peanut butter even though peanuts are officially a legume. For those with established heart disease to add more saturated fat that is in nuts is inappropriate. For people with no heart disease who want to eat nuts and avocado and are able to achieve a cholesterol of 150 and LDL of 80 or under without cholesterol lowering drugs, some nuts and avocado are acceptable. Chestnuts are the one nut, very low in fat, it is ok to eat."

Seeds (sunflower, pumpkin, sesame, etc.) Are seeds ok to eat?

Answer by Esselstyn: "1-2 tablespoons of ground flax seeds or chia seeds daily for omega 3 are appropriate for everyone to eat including heart patients, if they wish. Some seeds baked in bread or crackers is acceptable. Just don't eat handfuls."

Chef AJ's Story: Some people have to eliminate all nuts and seeds (and even avocados) from their system for losing weight. I understood this point better after listening to this talk: Chef AJ: From Fat Vegan to Skinny Bitch (58 min, YouTube), hosted by John McDougall. This is a fantastic, powerful, emotional talk in which Chef AJ spills her guts out — she is an excellent speaker! In the latter half, Chef AJ focuses more on the diet that she followed after meeting McDougall; she explains how doctors like Jeff Novick helped her eliminate nuts and seeds (and even avocados) to help her lose weight.

Calorie Density

How does WFPB without any calorie counting or portion control (with the exception of nuts n seeds) work? Because we have eliminated calorie dense and addictive foods! For details, see Calorie Density and Food Addictions.

Dr Klaper
(4 mins, 2020) Counting Calories - Do We Need To Limit Calories On A Plant-Based Diet?

YouTube video description:

Dr. Klaper shares his advice on what types of foods offer the best fuel and whether or not we need to count calories on a plant-based diet. He describes plant-based foods as 'clean' calories that the body can readily burn while absorbing maximum nutrition.

(6 mins, 2020) Macronutrients - Burning Carbohydrates, Fats & Protein

YouTube video description:

Dr. Klaper describes how the body burns carbohydrates, fats & protein, and in what order. He makes it clear that we are carbohydrate burning organisms and that fat and protein are secondary fuels. He also dispels the myth that we need to be overly concerned about counting these macronutrients when we eat a whole food plant-based diet.

Dr Brooke Goldner
(4 mins, 2022) Stop Counting Calories
(5 mins, 2020) Stop Counting Calories
© Copyright 2008—2025, Gurmeet Manku.