About
Instagram
YouTube
Disclaimer
Why Don't Doctors Recommend WFPB?
29 Oct 2020
Disclaimer
As of 2020, even after so many medical and governmental organizations have endorsed plant-based guidelines, why don't doctors recommend WFPB to their patients? A paper published in Kaiser Permanente explains the dynamics lucidly:

Publication: Is There a Lack of Support for Whole-Food, Plant-Based Diets in the Medical Community? by Maximilian Andreas Storz, MD, The Permanente Journal, Vol 23, No 1

My understanding of the three points in this publication:

(1) Doctors don't get paid to give nutrition advice to patients: doctors walk on an economic treadmill characterized by "diagnose & treat (with medicines & procedures)", with as few minutes spent per patient as possible; this maximizes profits for organizations that employ them. Nutrition advice & coaching can't be given in 10-15 mins; it requires hours & hours of education & is not as profitable. A medical doc who comes in touch with WFPB guidelines faces an ethical dilemma: "What exactly is my profession about? Should I be teaching people WFPB guidelines instead of practicing medicine as I was taught in medical school? Would that mean that I will make less money than what I make today?" In fact, the entire medical community faces this question as a collective: if 60% to 70% of chronic conditions can be prevented (and even reversed to a large degree) by simply adopting healthy lifestyle habits, what do we need so many medical doctors for? One of the main reasons is that most doctors aren't even familiar with these guidelines! Why?

(2) Lack of nutrition education as part of medical training: The vast majority of doctors are not educated in nutrition. They themselves fall sick to the same diseases. And they don't actually know that we can treat the vast majority of modern chronic lifestyle conditions through lifestyle changes alone! Check out Personal Stories of 20+ Whole Food Plant-Based doctors: not a single doctor in these stories learnt about WFPB as part of their medical training. They came in touch with WFPB via ForksOverKnives documentary, or through Google searches, or through patients' who experienced remarkable results through adoption of plant-based diet, or through chance contact with medical literature on WFPB. None of these doctors learnt about the profound relationship between food and disease in medical school. Today, ACLM (American College of Lifestyle Medicine) has come into being to help awaken doctors of this amazing approach to treating medical conditions but their outreach is still limited. The emphasis in medical school is treatment with with pharmacology (drugs) and invasive procedures. The idea that a serious disease could be prevented or cured by making changes to our food choices is rarely taught in medical schools.

(3) Patients expect quick results with pills and procedures: Patients are not attuned to the idea of making lifestyle changes to possibly reverse serious medical conditions. Soap operas, hospital movies and pharmaceutical ads make patients believe that the only way to treat chronic conditions is through medicines & procedures; the idea that simply changing our food habits could help us reverse a serious medical condition is met with incredulity: "Really? I came to you to figure out what to do about my chest pain and my diabetes[ and you're asking me to give up meat, fish, eggs, dairy, processed foods, oils & sugars? What are you talking about? You must be kidding, doc!"

Dr Esselstyn

Research paper: A plant-based diet and coronary artery disease: a mandate for effective therapy by Dr Caldwell Esselstyn, J Geriatric Cardiology, 2017 May; 14(5):317-320. Excerpts:

"For years, I have resisted making the suggestion that compensation ($$) could be an issue in decision-making. However, multiple lawsuits have arisen in cases where unnecessary stenting or bypass surgery was performed for nonexistent or minimal lesions. [24][25] Results of multiple investigations consisting of thousands of patients all show that stenting in an emergency situation is lifesaving while at the same time fails to prolong life or protect against future heart attacks in most patients undergoing elective stent placement when compared with optimal medical therapy. It is particularly disingenuous for physicians to tell patients that they are a walking time bombs — frightening them into accepting a procedure fraught with potential morbidity and possible mortality that is also non-curative — after an angiogram confirms a 90% blockage. Present day angiography does not identify, and angioplasty does not treat, the lesions that are most likely to cause a heart attack.[26]"

"Accepting the fact that most cardiovascular physicians are honest, caring, and compassionate, why do they resist WFPBN? Cardiovascular medicine practitioners receive essentially no nutrition education in medical school or postgraduate training. Therefore, they lack not only the skill set needed to help their patients modify their diets but also a basic awareness that plant-based nutrition can halt and reverse CVD. I recall a lawyer with CAD and angina who rapidly improved following WFPBN. He became quite angry after a follow-up visit to his cardiologist who said he knew WFPBN might be successful. The lawyer asked, "Why didn't you offer it to me many months ago?" and the cardiologist replied, "In my experience patients won't follow that program." Where upon the lawyer stated, "That must be my decision, not yours." It is not the message that is wrong but how and if the message is articulated that determines adherence and success.

Dr Peter Rogers
(11 mins, 2022) Does Science Need God?

Previous version: here (11 mins, 2022)

(5 mins, 2023) There's No Money In Educating You — You're On Your Own!
(Paucity Of) Nutrition Education

Paucity of Nutrition Education: Surprisingly, nutrition education is minimal (almost missing) in medical schools! Plant-based nutrition education is almost non-existant.

Nutrition Education Bill in California: In 2011, an attempt was made by Dr John McDougall to introduce a bill in California to make sure that doctors undergo 11 hours of nutrition education. Dr Greger has a 4-part video series explaining how the bill was opposed by medical associations and what finally became of the bill.

Why Do Doctors Eat Meat, Fish, Eggs & Dairy?: The vast majority of doctors are not trained in nutrition!

Why Is Nutrition So Confusing To Doctors & Researchers? What do editors of prestigeous medical journals say about medical research? Why is medical research and nutrition research so confusing?

Code Blue: Financial Incentives: An excerpt from Code Blue (documentary, 98 mins, 2020) in which doctors discuss these themes: Why do so few doctors practice Lifestyle Medicine? Why are so many doctors themselves confused about dietary guidelines? Why are most doctors not knowledgeable about the profound role of nutrition in preventing and treating chronic lifestyle conditions?

Why Don't Doctors Recommend Veganism? WFPB luminaries share their personal views on why veganism or plant-based guidelines are not recommended by medical doctors.

Dr Greger on Lifestyle Medicine: A series of videos by Dr Greger shedding light on various aspects of Lifestyle Medicine, an emerging discipline within medicine in USA.

Resources for Clinicians: ACLM resources (papers, courses, conferences), WFPB conferences targeted at clinicians, and other websites.

More Info

Extra Faith in Pills & Procedures: Dr Greger has videos explaining that patients overestimate the efficacy of pharmaceutical and surgical interventions! If they really knew the odds of success of these interventions and the odds and severity of side effects, they may be more inclined to adopt lifestyle changes for prevention, management and reversal of various chronic diseases. Dr Greger also has some videos explaining 'iatrogenic causes' caused by medical errors.

Meals at Rush University Hospitals: A 2-page story published in IJDRP: what happened when a team of WFPB doctors (including Dr Kim Williams, former President of American College of Cardiology) made an attempt to introduce plant-based meals at Rush University Hospital? Sadly, only minor progress was made.

© Copyright 2008—2025, Gurmeet Manku.